Customized plug valve vs. ball valve: a battle of performance and efficiency
Home » Blog » Industry news » Customized plug valve vs. ball valve: a battle of performance and efficiency

Customized plug valve vs. ball valve: a battle of performance and efficiency

Views: 56     Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2024-10-24      Origin: Site

facebook sharing button
twitter sharing button
line sharing button
wechat sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
sharethis sharing button

Plug valves and ball valves are very important applications used in industrial manufacturing and fluid control. Therefore, in some particular cases, the selection of the right type of valve might improve the efficiency of production as well as ensuring the security of the system. This paper focuses mainly on the structures and working principles of ball valves and plug valves, compares the processes of customizing them, and also highlights some critical issues concerning OEM and custom valve production.


1.Basic structure and working principle of plug valves and ball valves


1.1 Structure and working principle of plug valvesb412621307544573682dea2d2130dcb9(1)(1)

The core structure of the plug valve consists of a valve core (usually cylindrical or conical) and a valve body. The valve core has a fluid channel running through it, and the flow direction and flow rate of the fluid are adjusted by rotating the valve core. The working principle of the plug valve is very simple. When the channel of the valve core is in the same direction as the pipeline, the valve is fully open; when the valve core rotates 90 degrees, the fluid channel is closed and the valve is closed.

1.1.1 Compact structure and simple design

 The plug valve has a simple design and is easy to maintain. It is often used in occasions with low switching frequency.

1.1.2 Applicable to a variety of media

 The plug valve can be used for gas, liquid and semi-solid media, especially for applications that require fast switching.

1.1.3 Good sealing performance

Due to its simple structure, the plug valve can achieve good sealing in a low pressure environment.



1.2. Structure and working principle of ball valves

The core component of the ball valve is a ball with a fluid channel, which can be rotated to control the opening or closing of the valve. The working principle of the ball valve is similar to that of the plug valve, but the valve core changes from a plug shape to a ball shape. When the channel of the ball is in the same direction as the pipeline, the valve opens; when the ball rotates 90 degrees, the valve closes. The advantages of the ball valve are:20241024-212915(1)(1)


1.2.1 Easy to operate and open and close quickly

The ball valve can be fully opened or closed by rotating 90 degrees, which is very suitable for occasions with frequent operations.

1.2.2 Low fluid resistance

Due to the smooth transition design between the ball and the inner wall of the pipe, the ball valve has almost no fluid resistance when fully open.

1.2.3 Good sealing

In particular, ball valves made of materials such as polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) can maintain good sealing in high pressure and corrosive environments.



2. Commonalities and differences between custom plug valves and ball valves

2.1 Commonality analysis

In the field of industrial fluid control, plug valves and ball valves are two common valve types, both of which are important industrial fluid control equipment and play a vital role.

2.1.1 Provide customized solutions

Both plug valves and ball valves can be customized according to specific industrial application requirements, including size, material, pressure rating and operation mode. This customization capability enables them to meet a variety of complex and professional working environments.

2.1.2 Commonalities in corrosion resistance and durability 

Usually, they can be made of high-strength and corrosion-resistant materials such as stainless steel, carbon steel, and alloy steel to ensure stability and long service life under harsh working conditions.



2.2 Difference comparison

Although they have something in common in some aspects, the differences in design and function are also very obvious. The following is a detailed comparison of the two valves in terms of flow characteristics, sealing design, and application occasions.


2.2.1 Flow characteristics: a contest between straight lines and curves

Custom plug valve: This valve is known for its linear flow characteristics. When the fluid passes through the custom plug valve, its flow path is relatively direct without too many twists and turns. This design makes custom plug valves excellent in applications where the direction of fluid flow needs to be precisely controlled, especially in applications where the direction of the fluid needs to remain consistent.

Ball valve: The design of the ball valve allows for fast switching in fluid control. When the valve is fully open, fluid can pass almost unimpeded, making the ball valve an ideal choice for applications where fluid flow needs to be quickly cut off or opened. This feature of the ball valve makes it particularly popular in systems that require frequent operation.


2.2.2 Seal design: complex vs. simple

Custom plug valve: The seal design of the custom plug valve is usually more complex. It uses a conical or cylindrical valve core to achieve the seal, which can provide a better seal in low-pressure applications. This sealing method of the custom plug valve gives it an advantage in applications where the sealing requirements are higher.

Ball valve: The seal design of the ball valve is relatively simple, but it may be more reliable in high-pressure applications. The contact area between the ball and the valve seat of the ball valve is larger, which elps to disperse the pressure and reduce the risk of leakage. This sealing characteristic of the ball valve makes it more suitable for applications with high pressure and high sealing performance requirements.


2.2.3 Applications: Low pressure vs. high pressure

Custom plug valve: In low pressure and medium and low temperature applications, the custom plug valve shows its unique advantages. Its size and operating characteristics make it an ideal choice in these occasions. These characteristics of the custom plug valve make it particularly important in systems that require precise control of fluid flow.

Ball valve: In high pressure applications, custom ball valves perform better. Especially in situations where frequent switching and rapid closing of fluids are required, the ball valve's fast response ability makes it the first choice. These characteristics of the ball valve give it an incomparable advantage in high pressure systems, especially in situations where rapid operation is required.



3. Commonalities and differences in the customized production and processing processes of the two valves


3.1 Common characteristics of customized production and processing processes

3.1.1 Requirements analysis and design stage

Whether it is a plug valve or a ball valve, the first step in custom production is a comprehensive analysis of the customer's needs. This includes a detailed understanding of key factors such as operating pressure, temperature, fluid type and operating frequency. Based on this information, design engineers design valves that meet performance requirements for different working conditions.

3.1.2 Material selection

Material selection is critical for both valves. Both plug valves and ball valves can usually be made of stainless steel, alloy steel, cast iron and other materials, depending on the required corrosion resistance, mechanical strength and special requirements of the working environment. Correct material selection can effectively improve the service life and performance of the valve.

3.1.3 Processing technology

The processing technology of both valves usually includes precision casting, CNC machining, surface treatment and other processes. These processes play a vital role in ensuring the sealing performance, structural strength and appearance quality of the valve. High-precision machining can make the fit between the plug or ball and the valve body closer, thereby improving the sealing performance of the valve.

3.1.4 Quality control

No matter what kind of valve it is, it must undergo strict quality control during the customized production process. Common tests include sealing testing, pressure testing and material testing to ensure that each product meets design standards. Through quality control, plug valves and ball valves are able to meet the safety and reliability standards required by our customers.



3.2 Differentiation of customized production and processing processes

3.2.1 Design complexity

The design of the plug valve is relatively simple, mainly relying on the close contact between the valve core and the valve body to achieve sealing, and is suitable for low-complexity application scenarios. The design of spherical valves is more complex and requires consideration of the precise fit between the ball and the valve seat. Especially in the processing of the sealing surface, higher precision and material selection are required. Therefore, custom production of ball valves is typically much more complex than plug valves.

3.2.2 Sealing technology

The sealing of plug valves depends on the shape and material of the valve core, while ball valves usually use polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) or other advanced sealing materials to ensure the sealing effect in high pressure and corrosive media. This requires special attention to the selection of sealing materials and processing technology when customizing ball valves.

3.2.3 Operation mode

Plug valves are manually operated; they have a simple structure. According to different kinds of needs at the time, the ball valve can either be electric, pneumatic, or hydraulic actuator. So, in customization, operation mode and compatibility on the ball valve need to be comprehensively considered.



4. Key points to note when OEM or customizing these two valves


4.1. Choose the right materialb7b204ac5c9afd21b05fa84695d6f9f4(1)(1)

The choice of material is the core issue that must be paid attention to when customizing plug valves and ball valves. Different working environments require different materials. For example, in high temperature and high pressure environments, high temperature resistant alloys or stainless steel are ideal choices, while in corrosive media, the use of corrosion-resistant materials (such as special alloys or plastics) is the key. Reasonable selection of materials can not only increase the life of the valve, but also ensure its reliability under extreme working conditions.


4.2. Accurate design and manufacturing process

During the customization process, the design and manufacturing process of plug valves and ball valves require high precision. This is especially true for ball valves. Due to the extremely high sealing requirements between the geometry of the ball and the valve seat, precision machining is required to ensure surface finish and sealing performance. In addition, for plug valves, the matching accuracy of the valve core and the valve seat also determines the sealing and service life of the valve.


4.3. Choice of customized actuators

Ball valves are often equipped with electric, pneumatic or hydraulic actuators in environments with high automation requirements. When customizing ball valves, it is necessary to select the appropriate actuator according to the system requirements and ensure its compatibility with the valve body design. Although plug valves can also be equipped with actuators, their operation is mostly manual, and the convenience of operation and working frequency need to be considered.


4.4 Quality Control and Performance Testing

Quality control is a major element when customizing plug valves and ball valves. To set up a product that will be able to realize customer expectations and work in all kinds of working environments, the production process should involve very rigid test procedures which include sealing tests, pressure tests, and corrosion resistance. These, therefore, serve not just as a means for verifying the performance of the valve but also as an important means by which it may be assured that the valve will work stably over long periods of use.


4.4.1 Quality control processes

Raw material inspection

All raw materials should be up to relevant industry standards and specifications before the beginning of production to ensure a sound basis for further production.

Production process monitoring

Regular quality inspections and performance tests are carried out throughout the production process to ascertain that each process meets pre-set quality specifications, which will in turn ensure product consistency and reliability.

Test of the finished product

Before the product leaves the factory gates, a final and thorough dimensional accuracy, quality of surface treatment, and functional test are to be conducted amongst other tests to guarantee that the valve will be able to meet the technical requirements when installed.


4.4.2 Performance Testing

After production, the valve should be tested for a series of performance tests to validate further its applicability and dependability. Those tests include:

Pressure test

It shall be the responsibility of the valve to prove its seal by containing the fluid without leakages at extreme conditions during its working life at the maximum working pressure.

Seal test

The valve shall block the fluid flow completely when closed as indicated even under high pressures.

Flow test

Measure the flow characteristics of the valve in the full open position o ascertain that the flow data of the valve coincides with the design requirements and guarantees performance in real applications.

 


In brief, custom plug valves and ball valves have specific features that make them advantageous in apposite applications. Plug valves cater to low-pressure instances that exercise care in controlling flow; conversely, ball valves respond well to high-pressure conditions because of their quick action. Acknowledgment of such design and performance variations will support the decision-making process related to the choice of valve. Eventually, the material choice, design precision, and quality control must be considered fully for ensuring the applicability and dependability in industrial usage.

Contact Us
  No. 6988 Sunshine Avenue, Wuxing Industrial Zone, Oubei Town, Yongjia County, Wenzhou City, Zhejiang Province
 info@wktipvf.com
  +86-138-0880-7901

Quick Links

Products

Online Form

Copyright © 2023 Shenzhen Weikente Valve Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Sitemap Technology by leadong.com | Privacy Policy